Four of the five biggest transfers in Premier League history happened in one summer. A teenager cost €95 million. A defensive midfielder went for more than most clubs’ entire squads. And Newcastle and West Ham quietly banked half a billion between them.
This was the summer the money stopped making sense. Here are the 20 biggest deals, counted down.
20. Johan Manzambi, Freiburg to Aston Villa, €60.00m
A club-record signing for Villa, and a necessary one after Youri Tielemans’ exit and Amadou Onana’s ACL injury gutted their midfield. The 20-year-old Swiss attacking midfielder is a ball-carrier first, comfortable receiving between the lines and driving at defenders rather than recycling possession sideways. Unai Emery’s system asks a lot of positional discipline, so the question is whether Manzambi’s instinct to roam gets coached into structure or coached out of him entirely.
Verdict: a big fee for a big talent, but Villa are betting on potential at the exact moment they needed certainty.
19. Rodri, Manchester City to Barcelona, €60.00m
The Ballon d’Or winner and 2026 World Cup Golden Ball recipient, moving on at 30 for a fee that looks almost apologetic. Rodri is the modern pivot in its purest form: he doesn’t just shield the back four, he sets the entire tempo of a match, controlling when a team accelerates and when it strangles the game. At Barcelona he inherits a midfield built for possession, which suits him perfectly.
Verdict: the bargain of the window by a distance, assuming the legs hold.
18. Maxence Lacroix, Crystal Palace to Chelsea, €60.70m
An aggressive, front-foot centre-back who defends forward rather than dropping off, Lacroix built his reputation at Palace on stepping into midfield to kill attacks before they develop. That’s exactly the profile a high line demands, and Chelsea’s defensive record last season made a serious addition non-negotiable. Pace to recover, physicality to duel, and enough on the ball to play out.
Verdict: unglamorous but sensible, which is not a phrase often applied to Chelsea’s recruitment.
17. Tijjani Reijnders, Manchester City to Al-Qadsiah, €61.00m
The fourth senior midfielder out of City this window, after Rodri, Bernardo Silva and Nico González. Reijnders is a genuine box-to-box operator, all lung capacity and late runs into the area, and he never quite found a fixed role in Manchester. The Saudi Pro League gets a player still in his prime.
Verdict: good business for City, who recouped serious money on a player who never fully clicked.16.
16. Jérémy Jacquet, Rennes to Liverpool, €63.60m
Rennes’ most expensive sale of all time, and a deal Liverpool lined up practically the moment the January window shut. The 20-year-old centre-back is quick, aggressive and comfortable defending huge spaces, which matters enormously in a Liverpool side that plays a high line and asks its defenders to cover ground behind it. Signed until 2031, he’s the direct rebuild after Ibrahima Konaté left as a free agent.
Verdict: a lot of money for a 20-year-old, but Liverpool’s record with young defenders earns them the benefit of the doubt.
15. Crysencio Summerville, West Ham to Al-Hilal, €64.50m
A direct, one-v-one left winger who thrives cutting inside onto his right foot, Summerville’s game is built on acceleration and unpredictability rather than end product consistency. Roma wanted him and would have kept him in European football. Al-Hilal simply paid more.
Verdict: a phenomenal fee for West Ham, and a reminder that Saudi money still sets the market ceiling.
14. Iliman Ndiaye, Everton to Manchester City, €70.00m
Won on deadline day after a straight fight with Tottenham. Ndiaye is a wonderfully press-resistant forward who receives the ball in tight areas and escapes pressure with close control rather than pace, which makes him ideal for a City side that constantly plays into congested spaces. He can operate off either flank or centrally.
Verdict: a strange amount of money for a player yet to hit double figures in a Premier League season, but the profile fits City perfectly.
13. Gonçalo Ramos, PSG to AC Milan, €74.00m
A proper penalty-box centre-forward in an era that keeps trying to abolish them. Ramos is a natural finisher with excellent movement across the last defender, and his hold-up play is far better than his reputation suggests. Milan have lacked a focal point for years.
Verdict: if Milan build service around him, this is money well spent. If they don’t, he’ll starve.
12. Carlos Baleba, Brighton to Manchester United, €75.90m
Brighton wanted north of £100 million for him a year ago, so United will feel they’ve timed this well. Baleba is a destroyer with a passing range, a No. 6 who wins the ball in his own half and then progresses it rather than laying it off. United’s midfield has needed exactly that profile for the best part of a decade.
Verdict: the closest thing to a genuine bargain in United’s recent history.
11. Anthony Gordon, Newcastle to Barcelona, €80.00m
Confirmed back in May, and one of the more surprising moves of the summer. Gordon is a relentless, direct left winger whose defensive work rate is genuinely elite for an attacker, and his running in behind gives Barcelona something their possession game has occasionally lacked: a threat that stretches defences vertically rather than passing around them.
Verdict: a fascinating stylistic gamble, and one that could transform how Barcelona attack.
10. Bruno Guimarães, Newcastle to Arsenal, €87.50m
The reigning Premier League champions in full win-now mode. Guimarães is one of the most complete central midfielders in world football, capable of controlling tempo, breaking lines with his passing and doing the ugly defensive work in equal measure. With genuine concerns over Declan Rice’s fitness, Arteta needed an established elite operator, not a project. At 28 he arrives in his absolute prime.
Verdict: expensive, but exactly the right signing at exactly the right time.
9. Sávio, Manchester City to Tottenham, €87.70m
Spurs smashing their record for a winger with two Premier League goals in two seasons at City, with a further £10 million possible in add-ons. Sávio at his best is a classic inverted left winger, quick feet, low centre of gravity, always looking to cut in and shoot. The talent has never been in question; the output has.
Verdict: the most obvious gamble on this list. Under De Zerbi he might finally get the freedom he needed.
8. Ayyoub Bouaddi, Lille to Manchester City, €95.00m
The most expensive teenage signing in Premier League history. At 18, Bouaddi already has a substantial base of Ligue 1 and Morocco international experience, and he plays with a calmness in central midfield that simply shouldn’t exist at that age. He reads danger early, breaks up play without diving in, and his first thought on receiving is always forward.
Verdict: an eye-watering fee for a teenager, but City rarely miss on this profile.
7. Mateus Fernandes, West Ham to Tottenham, €99.00m
Spurs casually smashing their own transfer record on a player who has been relegated with both Southampton and West Ham, which tells you everything about how good he must be. At 21 he’s an all-round midfielder who can genuinely do it all: press, carry, pass through lines, and arrive late in the box. De Zerbi was reportedly central to convincing him.
Verdict: the fee is enormous, but the profile is exactly what Tottenham’s midfield has lacked.
6. Sandro Tonali, Newcastle to Tottenham, €108.00m
Spurs’ second club-record signing in quick succession, with more possible in add-ons. Tonali is a deep-lying orchestrator with the aggression of a destroyer, a rare and valuable combination. He dictates from the base, tackles like a No. 6 and passes like a No. 8.
Verdict: if he stays fit, Tottenham have signed a genuinely elite midfielder. That’s a big if.
5. Yan Diomande, RB Leipzig to Real Madrid, €125.00m
Liverpool wanted him. PSG thought they had him. Leipzig held firm and Madrid paid. The 19-year-old right winger is explosive in a straight line with a genuinely frightening top speed, and unusually for a player that quick, he’s a decisive finisher rather than just a runner. Add-ons could push the total to around £115-120 million.
Verdict: a colossal fee for a teenager, but Madrid have made a habit of paying early and being proved right.
4. Bradley Barcola, PSG to Liverpool, €125.00m
Liverpool had to be patient, and even at £106 million with add-ons potentially taking it to £123 million, they still came in well below PSG’s initial £145 million valuation. Barcola is a direct, left-sided runner who attacks the space behind full-backs and is at his most dangerous receiving in transition. At PSG he was behind Désiré Doué and Kvaratskhelia; at Liverpool he’s the main event.
Verdict: an overpay by most measures, but Liverpool have bought a 23-year-old at the start of his peak.
3. Elliot Anderson, Nottingham Forest to Manchester City, €135.00m
A club-record signing for City and, briefly, the most expensive British player of all time. Anderson’s numbers at Forest last season were absurd: the most duels won in the entire league (297) by a distance, the most touches (3,308), and he took the set pieces too. His profile is heavily Rodri-coded, a press-resistant passer who defends properly and drives the ball forward.
Verdict: replacing Rodri is close to impossible, and this fee means anything less than excellence will be judged a failure.
2. Morgan Rogers, Aston Villa to Chelsea, €138.00m
At £117 million, Rogers briefly became the most expensive English player in history. He’s a genuinely versatile attacker, comfortable at No. 10 or drifting from the wing, and his key trait is carrying the ball through midfield at speed rather than waiting to receive in the final third. Partnering him with Cole Palmer gives Chelsea two creators who both want the ball in dangerous areas.
Verdict: enormous money, but Chelsea’s attack lacked consistency last season and Rogers is the fix.
1. Enzo Fernández, Chelsea to Manchester City, €145.00m
The biggest deal of the window, completed after dramatic deadline-day negotiations. Fernández reunites with Enzo Maresca, the manager who got the best out of him, and arrives as the passing hub City lost when Rodri departed. He’s a rhythm-setter, a player who receives under pressure, turns out of it, and picks the pass that breaks a block. Three and a half years after Chelsea paid £106.7 million for him from Benfica, they’ve turned a profit.
Verdict: the right player for the vacancy, at a price that would have been unthinkable three years ago and now barely raises an eyebrow.
What this window actually told us
Four things, all happening at once.
The money has gone genuinely mental. A teenager at €95 million. A 20-year-old defender at €63 million. Fees that would have been world-record territory a decade ago now sit at number 15 on the list.
The Premier League is buying the planet. Fifteen of these 20 deals involve an English club as the buyer, and four of the top five most expensive transfers in Premier League history happened this summer alone.
It was the summer of the central midfielder. Enzo, Anderson, Tonali, Fernandes, Bouaddi, Guimarães, Baleba, Rodri, Reijnders. Nine of the top 20, all in the engine room, in a market that spent a decade telling us goalscorers were the only thing worth paying for.
And two clubs funded half of it. Newcastle sold Tonali, Guimarães and Gordon. West Ham sold Fernandes and Summerville. Between them, they banked well over £350 million while watching their best players leave.
City spent big and lost more midfielders than they signed. Tottenham broke their record twice in a month. Chelsea sold their most expensive signing ever and immediately replaced him with a more expensive one.
Which of these will look like a masterstroke in three years, and which will look like the moment a club lost the plot?
Leave a Reply